A study to identify the sexual health
problems of young married women in selected urban slums of Madurai, Tamil Nadu
Juliet Sylvia1*,
Dr. Basavanthappa2, Dr. Richard3
1Doctoral Student cum Professor in Nursing, Sacred Heart Nursing
College, Madurai -20
2Guide, Principal , Rajarajeswai College of Nursing ,Bangalore .
3Consultantant in Biostatistics, CMCH, Vellore.
*Corresponding Authors E-mail: julietsylvia@yahoo.co.in
ABSTRACT:
Background: There are significant gaps in the
scientific literature concerning sexual problems of young women the sexual
health of young women have not received adequate attention.
Objective: To study the sexual health problems of
young women in selected slums. These
study findings would help in preparing
appropriate strategies
for promoting the sexual health of women.
Methods: Using survey approach 155 young women in
the age group of 15-24 years were interviewed. Their current levels of sexual
problems were assessed using modified Brief index of Sexual Functioning for
women.
Results: only 30% of the participants had reported
about sexual health problems. Among
that head ache, anxiety, pain during sexual activity, sexual humiliation and
sex without consent were experienced by nearly 10% of the participants.
Conclusion: Further studies are required to study this
sensitive area in–depth. Nurses must be equipped with the necessary skills to provide Youth
friendly sexual health services.
KEY WORDS: Sexual health, Sexual health problems
INTRODUCTION:
Sexual health is the ability to express
one’s sexuality free from the risk of sexually transmitted infections (STIs),
unwanted pregnancy, coercion, violence, and discrimination. It means being able
to have an informed, enjoyable, and safe sex life, based on a positive approach
to sexual expression and mutual respect in sexual relations. It is positively
enriching, includes pleasure, and enhances self-determination, communication,
and relationships1
Scientific study in the area of sexuality
in India is
scant and if studied they have focused
on male sexual disorders.22Little is known about the prevalence of
sexual dysfunction in people attending their general practice and such problems
are rarely recognized by doctors.2
The first study in India which
systematically enquired into female sexuality among married young women in
North India reported that more than half of the sample (58%) admitted having
inhibition or anxiety while performing sexual activity.
A total of 17% participants encountered one
or more difficulties during sexual activities in the form of headache (10%),
difficulty in reaching orgasms (9%) painful intercourse (7%) lack of vaginal
lubrication (5%), bleeding after intercourse and vaginal infection (2%). Some attributed these problems due to spouses
health problems (4%) and conflict with spouse (4%)3.
Apart from the above disorders of sexual functioning the young women may encounter problems related
to engaging in sexual relationship with
their partner like abuse and unsafe sex predisposing to the risk of acquiring
HIV.
UNDP/UNFPA / WHO investigated areas of sexual and reproductive
health care of young people, including adolescents (aged 10.19 years) and youth
(aged 15.24 years)in 20 countries . In every setting, sexual activity begins
during adolescence among many young people. Much of this activity is risky.
Contraceptive use is often erratic and unwanted pregnancy and unsafe abortions
are observed in many settings. Sexual relations may be forced. There are wide
gender-based differences in sexual conduct, and in the ability to negotiate
sexual activity and contraceptive use. Despite this, relatively few young
people think they are at risk of disease or unwanted pregnancy. Awareness of
safe sex practices seems to be superficial, and misinformation regarding the
risks and consequences of unsafe sex is wide- spread4 .A study
examined the partner abuse and HIV risk among 2058 sexually active young adult
women. Young, sexually active women experiencing no abuse in their
relationships were more likely to consistently use condoms in the past 12
months than with their abused counterparts.
A casual pathway may exist between prior abuse, current abuse and HIV
risk5.
A study that explored the sexual coercion and abuse among 146
women with a severe mental illness in NIMHANS, India revealed the following
findings. Sexual coercion was reported by 30% involving threatened or actual
physical force and the most commonly identified perpetrator was the woman's
husband or intimate partner (15 percent), or a person in a position of
authority in their community (10 percent). Women with a history of abuse were
more likely to report HIV-related sexual behavior (P .001). In contrast to the
30 percent of women who reported sexual coercion during interviews, only 3.5
percent of the medical records contained this information. Increased screening
and reporting are indicated, as are sexual abuse prevention and treatment
programs.6
Keeping in view of the above
mentioned facts
and non availability of data from young women in slums a study on the sexual health problems of
young women is warranted.
Aim:
To identify the sexual health problems of young women in slums
MATERIALS AND METHODS:
The study was a cross sectional survey of 155 healthy young women residing in 5
different slums .The participants were selected from the general population
using stratified sampling technique if fulfilled the following inclusion
criteria.
Inclusion criteria
Age between 15-24 years
Married and staying continuously with the spouse for at least two months .
Instrument
A self report
instrument was developed and modified from Brief index of sexual functioning
for women (7) . It has 13 items scored on a 3point scale
(0-2).
Data collection procedure
The
tool was administered after getting the informed consent from each
participant. The
participants were interviewed in a convenient place. Confidentiality and anonymity were ensured.
RESULTS:
1. Demographic Characteristics
More than 50% of young women were below 19 years of age. Nearly 80% of them were Hindus and
unemployed. Three fourth of the subjects
were living in slums for more than 10 years. Only 30% of the subjects had
completed a higher secondary education.
Partner of the married (60%) and father of the unmarried were the key decision makers for
medical expenses. About occupation, 73.55% of married women were home makers,
the rest involved in jobs like coolie, supportive jobs in private companies,
small scale industries, corporate cleaning work etc. The socioeconomic status
of the subjects revealed that only a small proportion of women (7.74%) were
having a family income above Rs.5000
Partner’s Characteristics: Nearly
60% of their partners were Coolie workers. Nearly 35% of
their partners were using alcohol and 25% were consuming tobacco.
Sexual health problems of young women:
Frequency and Percentage Distribution of
Married Women According to Severity of Sexual Problems (N=155)
Table-1:
Variable |
f |
% |
I. Sexual Problems |
|
|
Present |
52 |
33.55 |
Absent |
103 |
66.45 |
II. Severity of Problem (n=52) |
|
|
Severe |
0 |
0 |
Moderate |
0 |
0 |
Mild |
52 |
100 |
Table 1 depicts that only 1/3rd (33.35%) had sexual
problems and out of those reported none had moderate or severe sexual problems.
Table-2:
Percentage Distribution of Married Women According to the Problems in
Sexual Relationship with their Partner (N=155)
Items Related
to Problems in Sexual Relationship |
Often |
Occasionally |
Never |
|||
f |
% |
f |
% |
f |
% |
|
Satisfied with
the relationship with their partner |
141 |
91 |
8 |
5.2 |
6 |
3.9 |
Head ache after
sex |
2 |
1.3 |
7 |
4.5 |
146 |
94.2 |
Unable to reach
orgasm |
2 |
1.3 |
7 |
4.5 |
146 |
94.2 |
Pain during sex |
2 |
1.3 |
15 |
9.7 |
138 |
89 |
Bleeding after
sex |
-- |
-- |
2 |
1.3 |
153 |
98.7 |
Infection of
genitalia |
2 |
1.3 |
2 |
1.3 |
151 |
97.4 |
Disinterest
towards sexual life |
4 |
2.6 |
12 |
7.7 |
139 |
89.7 |
Anxiety during
sex |
3 |
1.9 |
9 |
5.8 |
143 |
92.3 |
Sex without
consent |
2 |
1.3 |
8 |
5.2 |
145 |
93.5 |
Sexual
humiliation |
-- |
-- |
5 |
3.2 |
150 |
96.8 |
Using unwanted
mode of sex |
3 |
1.9 |
2 |
1.3 |
150 |
96.8 |
Has a doubting
partner |
3 |
1.9 |
1 |
0.6 |
151 |
97.4 |
Sickness
limiting sexual contact |
3 |
1.9 |
12 |
7.7 |
140 |
90.3 |
Only 1.3% had expressed that problems like headache, unable to
reach orgasm, infection in genitalia, sexual violence, pain were present often either during
or after sex. 1.9% of women expressed that their partner had humiliated or used
unwanted mode of sex or doubted them. 2.6% had disinterest towards sexual life
often as table -2
Few subjects came out with their problems such as:
“Husband doubts me, does not respect me at all. We always fight
with each other. So we don’t have relationship.” “My husband was working
abroad. He revealed to me that he once had sexual relationship with a
foreigner. Till now we don’t have an offspring. But he keeps me happy.” On the whole, women did not experience
severe sexual problems. The reasons that
can be attributed may be underreporting, being in early marital life or having
inhibitions to express themselves.
But the results of the study conducted among 1664 married young
women in Gujarat, India revealed that 12% of married women experienced unwanted
sex frequently; 32% experienced occasionally which is more than the present
study findings3. Even in the study carried out in Nigeria 15% had
forced sexual intercourse8
In Asian Studies there is under reporting of sexual dysfunction by
females which may be because they are young age groups. Self reports about
sexual dysfunction, especially face to face interviews are subject to under
reporting bias arising from concerns of social stigmatization, low emphasis on
female sexual satisfaction, poor attitude toward health care professionals
which require further evaluation in future studies3.
LIMITATION:
The present study is a preliminary effort to understand the sexual
health problems of young women. Being a younger age group a few percentage of the sample only
reported about sexual health problems.
Neither were they interested in undergoing a clinical examination. Many
cultural factors could have had an impact on the study findings .Future studies
should explore the sexual health knowledge, attitude, behaviour, disorders and
HIV risk of this population.
NURSING IMPLICATIONS:
The Nurses as a Role Model
The nurse’s attitudes, biases and
prejudices regarding sexuality are readily transmitted to patients through his
or her actions, manner of speech, avoidance of certain circumstances, and types
of discussion. The level of knowledge a
nurse has about sexual issues can inhibit or promote discussions of sexual
health.
This model offers four levels of sexual health counselling;
it encourages nurses to intervene at the level at which they feel comfortable.
The four levels are described as follows :
- Give Permission (P). Convey to the
client or relatives that you are willing to discuss sexual thoughts and
feelings.
- Offer Limited Information (LI) on
the implications of, for example, being pregnant, having cancer or being
prescribed a particular medication.
- Make Specific Suggestions (SS) Provide
specific instructions that facilitate positive sexual functioning, such as
coital positions for women with arthritis.
Provide Intensive Therapy (IT) Clients needing this type of
approach should be referred to nurses with advanced knowledge of sex therapy,
or to specialist therapist.
Nursing education
The promotion of sexual health is a
legitimate role for the nurse.. Unfortunately, the
exploration of sexual health in many nursing education programmes
is frequently inadequate. Teachers of nursing are often unprepared and
unskilled in promoting learning experiences focused on human sexuality and
sexual health and HIV/STI
risk.1
During the exploratory discussion, try to
elicit information about key issues in order to assist the client to perceive
and determine his or her risk for STIs, including: Number (and gender) of sexual partners
currently and in the past, Knowledge of partner’s sexual practices and other
partners, Condom use, History of STIs/ infections and Sexual
practices and behaviors9.
There is a global
need for: adolescent- and youth-friendly sexual and reproductive health
services; counselling on sexuality, pregnancy,
post-abortion issues and family planning; and sex education programmes
that are age-appropriate and sensitively imparted.
Nurses Role in Research
Investigate the gender roles and life skills that affect the
health situation of young women
Explore the issues of sexual coercion concerning both married and
unmarried youth
Investigate young people's access to health care, and the
constraints they face in the pursuit of good health.
STRATEGIES AND RECOMMENDATION
1. Programmatic
Recommendations
Build life skills among youth
Address gender disparities
Raise awareness of sexual force and
coercion, and equip youth to counter them
Dispel myths and misconceptions
Provide information through media
acceptable to youth
Involve parents in communicating
information on safe sex behaviour
Involve youth in programmes
aimed at imparting information and developing educational strategies
Promote access to confidential and private sexual and reproductivhealthcareservice
2. Promote Sexual Health
Successful promotion of sexual health requires a comprehensive programme of activities, encompassing the health and
education sectors, as well as the broader political, economic and legal domains
World2
3. Integrating
Sexual Health into Primary Health Care Services
Strategies to integrate aspects of sexual health into MCH services
include:
č Provision of voluntary and confidential counselling and testing for HIV
č Education about HIV prevention, condom use
and prevention of STIs, prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV
infection.
COGNITIVE SKILLS
Strong Knowledge base on
Human sexuality, myths, anatomy, physiology Factors
affecting Integrate knowledge into nursing
care
|
|
INTERPERSONAL SKILLS
To establish trusting relationship, and build rapport Demonstrate
non judgmental attitude respect for dignity Counselling skills Motivate
coping behaviors |
|
|
|
TECHNICAL SKILLS
Assessment skills
for interviewing concern about sexuality Ability
to adapt techniques for
patients with problems affecting sexual health
Seek help when necessary |
|
ETHICAL AND LEGAL SKILLS
Commitment to safety and quality Strong sense of
accountability Commitment
to patient advocacy Familiarity
with agency policy Practice
in an ethically and legally defendable manner. |
Figure-1
CONCLUSION:
The study findings showed that the young women in slums are a
vulnerable group and they experience
sexual health risks to some extent. Availability of youth friendly reproductive
and sexual health services would help in alleviating the myths and inhibition
associated in expressing their problems.
REFERENCES:
1. Engender Health.
Sexuality and Sexual Health online Mini course 2005. (http
://www.engenderhealth.org/pubs/index.html)
2. Mercer CH, et al.
Sexual function problems and help seeking behaviour in Britain: BMJ 2003; 327:
pp.426–427. [Online] Available from: http://www.bmj. com/cgi/content/ full/ 327/ 7412/426. (Accessed
on 20th Jun. 2009).
3. Avasthi
A, Kaur R, Prakash O, Banergee A, Kumar L & Kulhara
P. Sexual behaviour of married young women. A preliminary
study from North India. Indian Journal of Community Medicine, 2008; 333
(3): pp.163-166.
4. Ann Denise Brown et
al., Sexual relations among young people in developing countries evidence from
WHO case studies, Department of reproductive Health and Reports, WHO, Geneva,
1998 (www.who.org)
5. Teitelman
AM, Ratcliffe SJ, Dichtder ME & Sullivan CM. Recent and past intimate partner
abuse and HIV risk among young women. Jobstet Gynec. Neonatal Nurs.
Mar-Apr 2008; 37(2): pp.219-27.
6. Chandra, P.S, Carrey,
M.P, Carry, K.B, Shalinianand, A. & Thomas. T.
Sexual coercion and abuse among women with a severe mental illness in India. Compr.
Psychiatry. 2005 May – June; 44(3) : 2005 – 212.
7. Rosen R et al. The female sexual function index. A
multidimensional self report instrument for the assessment of female sexual
function. Journal of Sex &
Marital Therapy, 2000; 26: pp.191-208
8. WHO. Sexually
Transmitted Infections, Reproductive Tract Infections, a guide to Essential
Practice, 2005; Department of Reproductive Health Research, WHO
9. Avasthi
A, Kaur R, Prakash O, Banergee A, Kumar L & Kulhara
P. Sexual behaviour of married young women. A preliminary
study from North India. Indian Journal of Community Medicine, 2008; 333
(3): pp.163-166
Received on 13.08.2012 Modified on 20.09.2012
Accepted on 16.10.2012 ©
A&V Publication all right reserved
Asian J. Nur. Edu. and Research 2(4): Oct-Dec. 2012;
Page 197-201